Why incompetent people are unaware of how incompetent they are cover image

Why incompetent people are unaware of how incompetent they are

Dorian Minors • May 22, 2015

This is an archived article from our predecessor website, The Dirt Psychology. The idea there was to take psychological scholarship and turn it into wisdom. The Armchair Collective tries to go a little further than just psychology. As such, these articles live here in archive form, until they're updated.

'You know nothing, Jon Snow', whispered Ygritte at the end. Or as Socrates said, 'the only true wisdom is that you know nothing'. Or to be more specific, Bertrand Russell put it, 'those who feel certainty are stupid, and those with any imagination and understanding are filled with doubt and indecision'. All very poignant ways of summarising what psychologist David Dunning and his colleagues discovered in 2003:

People base their perceptions of performance, in part, on their preconceived notions about their skills. Because these notions often do not correlate with objective performance, they can lead people to make judgments about their performance that have little to do with actual accomplishment.
No Jim, that's not... more things aren't going to make you more productive. No Jim, that's not... more things aren't going to make you more productive.

Clearly, we have work to do in getting our psychologists to be quite as efficient at communicating as Ygritte. Maybe an exile to the North. Essentially, they're saying that we assess how good we are at something by how good we assume we are based on our experiences. This isn't surprising, really. I mean, no one knows us as well as we know us. In fact, we could be considered 'experts' on ourselves. A scary thought perhaps, and something that causes several problems. But David's finding poses an interesting problem, which we can glean from his far more succinct title:

Why People Fail to Recognize Their Own Incompetence

The more talented you are at something, the less accomplished we feel and the less 'good' we assume we are at that same something. Or, put another way, the more incompetent you are, the more confidence you have in your ability. This is a result that has been proven again, and again, and again (and again) with all sorts of people. Basically, incompetent people are simply unaware of how incompetent they are. It's called the Dunning-Kruger effect.

How to fix it?

Well, this effect is probably because the more practiced and knowledgeable you are about something, the more you recognise the complexities involved and thus, just how much goes into being skilled at something. So, a good long term strategy is to get the incompetent person more involved in whatever they're doing. Or, for something more short term, as Dunning and his colleagues propose, just tell the person directly how incompetent they are (another reason to exile psychologists to the North). Ever had someone quote statistics at you, even though you know full well they have no idea what they're talking about? Learn why statistics are flawed here (and why so many dopey people use them anyway). Worried you're ignorant? Well, there's probably nothing you can do about that right now, but maybe you can fool people by learning the psychology behind awesome first impressions, here. Giving you the dirt on your search for understanding, psychological freedom and 'the good life', at The Dirt Psychology.

Turning scholarship into wisdom we can use at The Armchair Collective.

Questions? Comments? Comment sections are a pain to moderate. But this inbox is always read, so send an email. You'll get a reply. Your question might even get a whole article of its own.

More articles? View them all, or check these out:

Dorian Minors

I mostly do brain science. Sometimes I train honeybees. I promise they're related. I made this site because there's no reason why scholars should be the only ones to own knowledge. My special interests are interpersonal relationships, the science of community, spirituality and the brain, and the neural basis of complex behaviour. I hope this stuff is as interesting to you as it is to me. You can find out more about me here.